How does XTherma differ from Oligio, HIFU, and Ulthera?

XTherma differs from Oligio, HIFU, and Ulthera primarily in the type of energy used. XTherma and Oligio use heat from radio frequency (RF) waves, while HIFU and Ulthera use focused ultrasound waves. This article compares the mechanism, sensation during treatment, and suitable patient groups, based on information from Fresh Code Clinic and medical reviews. This information is for general knowledge purposes only and is not a diagnosis.

Key Takeaways

  • Xtherma and Oligio are in the monopolar RF category, which use heat to stimulate collagen, while HIFU and Ulthera are in the ultrasound category, which deliver energy in deep points. The review notes that both RF and focused ultrasound are used for facial and neck sagging, but they are not intended to replace surgery.
  • The sensations during treatment differ. RF is typically warm or hot (in Thermage studies, most patients reported a “warm” feeling), while focused ultrasound pain varies depending on the area and the individual. The average in a review was around 2-4 out of 10, and higher in the eyebrow and periorbital areas.
  • There is no single best method for everyone. Reviews indicate that those with mild to moderate sagging are best suited for this, while those with significant sagging are often better prepared for surgery. In some cases, doctors may use more than one technology in combination.
  • The clinic states that no downtime is required, but research has found temporary redness and swelling. Independent studies available do not include any research on XTherma; there is one study on Oligio (30 people, followed for 6 months, no control group), and the rest are on other machines (Thermage, Ulthera). A doctor's evaluation is recommended before choosing this treatment.

There are many types of facelift procedures. How do they differ?

Currently, there are many non-surgical facelift technologies available, including XTherma, Oligio, HIFU, and Ulthera. Many people ask themselves before making a decision, "What are the differences between them?" and "Which one is right for me?"“[1]

The clinic explained that no single technology is suitable for everyone. Choosing what's right for your skin condition, skin problems, and expectations is more important than choosing based solely on the name of the device.[1] This article describes the differences in mechanism of action, sensation during use, and suitable user groups, supplemented by information from medical reviews.

Overview first: How many groups are there for skin tightening technologies?

Non-surgical facelift procedures are categorized into two main groups based on the energy used, as explained by the clinic.[1]

Group 1: Radiofrequency (RF)

Thermal energy is used to stimulate collagen production. Examples include XTherma and Oligio.[1]

Group 2: Ultrasound (sound waves)

It uses ultrasound waves to penetrate specific layers of the skin. Examples include HIFU and Ulthera.[1]

Differences in energy groups affect the feeling, depth, and expected results, as explained clinically.[1] A review of skin tightening technologies indicates that RF and focused ultrasound are both used for facial and neck sagging, stimulating collagen restructuring through heat. The majority of patients in the studies were highly satisfied, but the authors note that these treatments are not intended as a replacement for surgery.[7]

What are RF groups: XTherma and Oligio?

What is XTherma?

XTherma is a Monopolar Radiofrequency (RF) technology that delivers thermal energy to the deep layers of the skin to stimulate the contraction of existing collagen fibers and promote the long-term production of new collagen, as explained by the clinic.[1] The clinic's service page further states that they use RF 6.78 MHz with a Skin Temperature Control (STC) system during treatment. The sensation is a combination of warmth or deep heat alternating with coolness, and the full results may not be visible on the day of treatment.[2]

Key features described by the clinic include wide-area energy distribution, focusing on overall skin rejuvenation and firmness, and suitability for those seeking firmer skin, a more defined facial contour, and natural-looking results.[1]

What is Oligio?

Oligio is also a monopolar RF technology, but it has a different energy delivery method and device head design. The clinic states that Oligio uses RF energy to break down certain fat deposits while tightening the skin. It focuses on working on multiple skin layers and is often chosen for cases of excess fat in the cheeks or chin along with sagging skin.[1]

The manufacturer's page (WONTECH ASIA) describes the Oligio X as using 6.78 MHz RF in a mode that works on both the upper and deeper layers of the skin, and claims it affects the cheek and chin areas without directly using the term "fat reduction."[3] Since this information is from the manufacturer and independent sources do not contain research confirming Oligio's fat-reducing effects, you should consult your doctor about the information and limitations before making a decision.

An Oligio study was conducted on 30 Thai adults (ages 43-53) with mild to moderate lower facial sagging. A single treatment was performed and followed at 1, 3, and 6 months. Two dermatologists, unaware of the treatment information, assessed the results based on images. Improvement of approximately 871 TP3T was observed at 6 months. The average pain score was approximately 3 out of 10, while temporary redness was approximately 831 TP3T and resolved within 1-2 days. No serious adverse events were reported. Limitations noted by the authors include the absence of a control group, largely subjective assessments, and the device being supplied by a distributor with open access to publication provided by the manufacturer. This study focused on sagging, not fat reduction.[9]

What does RF feel like, and how much independent data is available?

Independent data for XTherma were not found, and Oligio's study only included the aforementioned work. The remaining data belonged to other monopolar RF models (Thermage/ThermaCool) and were therefore used only as an overview of the RF group. In the 20-patient study, the primary discomfort was heat. Patients with 70% found the level to be “warm” and those with 30% found it to be “slightly to moderately hot,” and all accepted these levels for subsequent treatments. The authors noted that no adverse events were observed in this study.[5] A retrospective study of over 600 treatments found redness and swelling, which usually resolved within 24 hours. Approximately 2.71 TP3T of the treatment was a temporary side effect, and no permanent side effects were observed. However, this was a retrospective study from a single center where the author was the treating physician.[6]

Ultrasound Group: What are HIFU and Ulthera?

What is HIFU?

HIFU (High Intensity Focused Ultrasound) uses high-intensity ultrasound waves to deliver energy to specific locations in the skin – "points" of energy – working at a specific depth. The sensation is often a sharp, tingling feeling in certain areas. The clinic recommends it for those seeking targeted lifting and structural skin tightening.[1]

What is Ulthera?

Ulthera, like HIFU, belongs to the ultrasound group. A key feature highlighted by the clinic is its visualization system during treatment. It uses high energy to target specific layers, resulting in a noticeable sensation in some areas. It's ideal for deep-level lifting and tightening, suitable for those seeking targeted lifting and who prefer a high degree of sensation during treatment.[1]

A review of microfocused ultrasound describes that the energy heats the tissue to approximately 60°C, causing collagen coagulation of about 1 cubic millimeter in size in the deep dermis and SMAS layer. Depending on the head used, the coagulation depth is around 4.5 mm, 3 mm, or 1.5 mm, and ultrasound imaging allows visualization of tissue up to about 8 mm during the procedure. The same article states that the energy per pulse of microfocused ultrasound is 0.18-1.2 joules, while HIFU is around 100 joules. This data is from 2016, and current equipment may vary.[4]

Regarding pain, the review noted significant variation across studies. Some averages ranged from around 1.9-4 out of 10, higher in the eyebrow and eye area (around 5.7 out of 10) compared to other parts of the face and neck. Common side effects included redness lasting up to 24 hours and swelling lasting up to 3 days. Less frequently reported problems included bruising, numbness, and linear scarring.[4]

Comparison table: XTherma vs Oligio vs HIFU vs Ulthera

The table below summarizes clinical data and adds rows of observations from medical reviews (results and feelings may vary from person to person).[1]

sectionXThermaOligioHIFUUlthera
Types of energyMonopolar RFMonopolar RFUltrasoundUltrasound
Energy characteristicsHeat distributionMultilayer heatingSound waves are points.Sound waves are points.
DepthBroad deep skin layerMultiple layers of skinSpecific depth pointsSpecific depth points
Feelings while doing itDeep and lasting warmth.Deep warmIt stings in some spots.A sharp, deep pain in certain locations.
HighlightsSkin rejuvenation + firmingSkin tightening + partial fat reduction (at a clinic)Lift only at specific points.Deep lifting with a system for visualizing the skin layers.
Who is it suitable for?I want to look naturally good.Contains fat.Emphasize key points.Highly sensitive
Recovery (at a clinic)No recovery time needed.No recovery time needed.No recovery time needed.No recovery time needed.
Observations from research.No independent studies were found for XTherma; other RF models showed temporary redness and swelling.[5][6]A study of 30 people with lower facial sagging, followed for 6 months, found no studies confirming fat reduction.[9]Model-specific HIFU information was not found in any accessible source.[4]Redness can last up to 24 hours, and swelling can last up to 3 days in some cases.[4]

Which type should I choose? And why should I consult a doctor before choosing a device?

Which one should I choose?

The answer isn't "which machine is better," but "which one is more suitable for your skin." The clinic recommends considering the degree of sagging, the amount of facial fat, sensitivity, and expected results. In many cases, your doctor may recommend combining more than one technology.[1]

Independent sources are consistent; a review of microfocused ultrasound indicates that it is best suited for individuals with mild to moderate sagging. Those with moderate to severe sagging are often more suitable for surgery, and the results are not as good as a facelift. A body mass index (BMI) less than 30 is associated with a better response. Contraindications include infection, open wounds, acne cysts, and pregnancy, and caution should be exercised when performing the procedure on the same day as fillers or botulinum toxin.[4]

An article in Dermatology Times states that RF is suitable for those with mild to moderate changes in skin quality and sagging, and that the results are comparable to non-surgical tissue repositioning. Informants suggest that a combination of treatments may yield better results. One informant mentioned working as a consultant for an RF device manufacturer.[8]

Why should you consult a doctor before choosing a device?

The clinic argues that being the same age doesn't mean having the same skin condition, similar skin problems don't necessarily mean using the same energy levels, and different lifestyles require different treatment plans. A case-by-case assessment allows for the selection of more targeted and cost-effective technology.[1] The clinic's service page also states that XTherma is not the best option for everyone, and cases with fatty or structural causes may require other plans.[2]

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

Q: What is the difference between XTherma and Oligio?

Both belong to the Monopolar RF group, which uses heat to stimulate collagen. The clinic states that XTherma focuses on overall rejuvenation and tightening with broad-area energy distribution, while Oligio has a different head design and energy delivery method and is often chosen for cases of cheek or chin fat combined with sagging, according to the clinic's explanation. No independent research has been found to confirm Oligio's fat-reducing effects.

Q: What are the differences between HIFU and Ulthera?

Both use ultrasound waves to deliver energy in pulses. The clinic states that Ulthera has a system for visualizing the skin layers during treatment. A 2016 review indicated that microfocused ultrasound uses 0.18-1.2 joules of energy per pulse, compared to around 100 joules for HIFU, and uses ultrasound imaging to visualize tissue depths of up to about 8 mm. Current devices may differ from this information.

Q: Is there a difference in sensation between RF and Ultrasound?

As clinically described, RF is typically felt as a continuous, deep warmth, while ultrasound is usually a localized tingling sensation. A 20-patient RF study, patient 70%, reported a level of “warmth.” A review of focused ultrasound reported an average pain of around 2-4 out of 10, and higher in the eyebrow and periorbital areas. Results varied from person to person.

Q: Do I need a recovery period after the procedure?

The clinic states that no downtime is required. Research has found temporary redness and swelling; for example, with RF, redness and swelling usually subside within 24 hours, while with ultrasound, redness can last up to 24 hours. Swelling can last up to 3 days in some cases. Less common side effects have been reported. Ask your doctor about symptoms to watch for.

Q: Which machine should I choose, or can I use multiple machines together?

There is no single best machine for everyone. The clinic recommends that a doctor assess the degree of sagging, fat, sensitivity, and expectations. In some cases, a doctor may use more than one technology in combination. An article in Dermatology Times indicates that doctors who provided information believe that using multiple methods together may yield better results. Those with significant sagging may, in turn, be more suitable for surgery.

Conclusion

Xtherma and Oligio use radio frequency (RF) waves to heat the skin and subcutaneous layers, while HIFU and Ulthera use focused high-frequency sound waves (ultrasound) to deliver energy in targeted points at specific depths. The main difference, therefore, lies in the type and method of energy delivery. There is no single "best" machine for everyone. Furthermore, there is a lack of independent research on Xtherma; there is one study on Oligio that followed you for 6 months without a control group. The remaining studies are on other machines in the same category (such as Thermage and Ulthera). Therefore, it's crucial to carefully review information regarding results. At Fresh Code Clinic, our doctors will assess your skin and facial structure on a case-by-case basis to select the most suitable machine or treatment program for you. We don't oversell or do unnecessary treatments.

Because effective skin tightening starts with understanding, not just the name of the device. The information in this article is general knowledge and not a diagnosis or guarantee of results. For more information, consult a doctor for evaluation first.

Fresh Code Clinic Team

Fresh Code Clinic is a beauty lifestyle clinic located in Sukhumvit Soi 5, near BTS Nana. It offers skin care services, acne treatment, laser treatments, skin tightening, fillers, and Botox, all provided by a team of expert doctors with personalized care tailored to each individual's skin condition.

19 Sukhumvit Soi 5, near BTS Nana, Exit 1. Parking available. Open daily 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM. Tel: 02-253-2236, 083-626-4264

References